Jackson, Mississippi Criminal Defense Lawyer Discusses Discovering the Identity of Confidential Informants

The police rely on confidential informants to make cases.  For obvious reasons, law enforcement goes to great lengths to keep the identity of informants secret.  However, in many instances, a person charged with a crime is entitled to find out who snitched on them.

Pursuant to Rule 9.04(B)(2) of the Mississippi Uniform Rules of Circuit and County Court,

[d]isclosure of an informant’s identity shall not be required unless the confidential informant is to be produced at a hearing or trial or a failure to disclose his/her identity will infringe the constitutional rights of the accused or unless the informant was or depicts himself/herself as an eyewitness to the event or events constituting the charge against the defendant.

The Mississippi Supreme Court explained Rule 9.04(B)(2) this way:

If a reliable informant tells officers, ‘if you go to point X you will find evidence,’ the identity of the informant may be withheld.  On the other hand, if the informant … says, ‘I will help you catch the suspect,’ and takes part in the police activity, or if the informant becomes a witness to the facts constituting a crime, he becomes a witness who may be required to appear at trial.

See Breckenridge v. State, 472 So.2d 373 (Miss. 1985).

Based upon these cases, there are two (2) types of confidential informants.  The first type is the informant who merely tells police about criminal activity, has nothing to do with the activity itself, and is not an eyewitness to the criminal activity.  This type of informant just gives police information.  The police then go and conduct their own investigation and build a case independently, without using the informant further.  In this circumstance, the Government is not required to disclose the identity of the informant.

The second type of informant is the one who actually participates, or claims to be an eyewitness to the crime.  This typically occurs in drug cases where informants make “controlled buys” for the police, or where they arrange drug transactions.  This also sometimes occurs when an informant has knowledge of criminal activity, gives this information to the police, and the police use the information to obtain a search warrant.  Under these circumstances, the Government is required to disclose the identity of the informant to the defense.

Discovering a snitch’s identity can be very helpful to the defense.  At a minimum, the defense lawyer should contact and attempt to interview the informant.  This interview can uncover facts which are helpful to the defense.  Furthermore, most informants are rather unsavory characters.  Many snitches have rap sheets that read like a roll of toilet paper.  If the case against the Defendant is based upon the word of such a rat, the defense may want to call this person as a witness at trial.  Putting the snitch on the witness stand may show the jury that they shouldn’t trust the Government’s evidence because of the source.  In other words, if they can’t trust the messenger, they can’t trust the message.

Whether or not a criminal defendant can find out who snitched must be analyzed on a case-by-case basis.  If you’ve been arrested and think a confidential informant may be involved, please call me to discuss your case.

Mississippi Criminal Defense Attorney Curt Crowley


One response to “Jackson, Mississippi Criminal Defense Lawyer Discusses Discovering the Identity of Confidential Informants

  1. I am skeptical about the use of police informants, yet with adequate respect of other constitutional rights in carrying out law enforcemnt acts maybe such is okay. The management of informants is mostly a matter of knowing what motivates them, and always making sure this motivation continues to have some currency. There are many motivation-based typologies of informants in the literature. However, sometimes informant can be helpfuland still have hidden motives which police overlook to make a case.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s